How To Find Out If Your Employees Are Faking Sickness

    It’s easy to assume that, when an employee calls in sick, they may not be telling the whole truth especially if you see this is a regular occurrence for one particular employee. But it is very rarely the case that an employee is lying and you should never jump to conclusions.

    How Do You Know If An Employee is Faking Sickness?

    To find out whether an employee is not being 100% honest about an illness, you will need clear evidence against them before making any accusations.

    This can be quite difficult, especially if there are only one or two days of absence because it’s a minor illness such as the flu or a stomach bug, but there are various things you can do if you are concerned that too much sickness absence is being taken.

    If you’re an employer or manager that needs to seek professional advice from a qualified HR expert about a specific issue regarding absence that has occurred at your business, then call us today on 0845 2626 260 or email us directly.

    Employees can self-certify for up to 7 days; however, following this they will need to present a medical note from their doctor which should be supplied to you from the eighth day of absence.

    You can also conduct a return to work interview to find out more about the illness and make sure that they are fit enough to go back to work. This will demonstrate to employees that their absence is being monitored and will discourage unnecessary regular absenteeism if they must sit in front of the manager every time they return to work.

    There may also be cases of whistleblowing in the workplace if colleagues have evidence that a fellow employee is faking sickness, such as posts on social media.
    If you are presented with such proof from another employee then you must gain permission from them for you to use it against their colleague.

    Please be wary though that covert surveillance and checking personal social media accounts as the employer can become questionable sources of evidence as you need to make sure that you are not invading the privacy of your employees especially under the recently updated privacy laws.

    If you happen to see your employee walking around town during lunch or posting pictures of their trip to the zoo on Facebook, then that can be used as sufficient evidence against them.

    What Process Should I Use for Collecting Evidence?

    The best way to track any suspicious behaviour is by keeping a record of sickness absence so you can pick up on questionable patterns such as does illness always seem to fall around pay day, or when the sun comes out?

    Long term sickness will probably raise the most eyebrows but, your sickness absence policy should implement clear guidelines from day one such as a doctor’s sick note being provided after a specified number of days off.

    If you have collected enough strong evidence for you to suspect that the employee is faking sickness, then it’s time to hold an investigation meeting.

    During this, you should approach the situation with ease and fairness to get to the root of the problem before making any accusations.

    How Should I Approach the Employee About My Suspicions?

    Start by finding out whether there are any external issues such as problems at home, grievances at work or real serious health issues that need to be addressed. It could be the case that the employee does have an illness but they do not want to disclose the full details so have fabricated another illness i.e. they may be struggling with mental health but have said they have a stomach bug. So you need to tread carefully and be mindful of the sensitive nature behind many illnesses.

    If you do discover that they have lied about being ill on multiple occasions and are unable to find any justifiable reasons for the dishonesty (and the unnecessary absence) then you can progress the situation to a disciplinary issue as this would be classed as breaking the code of conduct set by your business.

    For further information on how to address a gross misconduct issue, please see our recent post entitled ‘Dealing with Gross Misconduct in The Workplace‘ or give us a call on 0845 2626 260 to book a free consultation.

    Call Guardian Support Button

    Get in touch with any questions

      Our Clients

      Berrys Fuelling Technologies Ltd
      Birmingham Football Club
      Costa Coffee
      Jemca Car Group
      Age UK
      Wolverhampton Wanderers F.C.
      Domino's Pizza